Episode 03: What If You're Part of the Problem?
0:00 / 12:24Watch

Episode 03 · Wednesday, Nov 18, 2026 · 12 min

What If You're Part of the Problem?

For two episodes I've been describing a sector that quietly changed its language and never wrote down why. There's an obvious problem with me saying that. I'm a brand communication strategist. If the language of the sector drifted, I wasn't watching from the shore. I was navigating at least one of those ships.

In this episode

Show notes

This episode is about what you do when the critique includes you. Being implicated doesn't disqualify you. It moves you from prosecutor to witness, and the witness is the one with something worth hearing.

Three questions to run before you say the thing:
1. Does this apply to my own work by the same standard?
2. Am I describing a decision or a person?
3. What would change my mind?

And one sentence to open with:
"Before I say anything about how we've been describing this, I wrote some of it, so this lands on me too."

CHAPTERS
0:00 Three questions
0:32 The obvious problem with me saying that
1:12 Welcome to In So Many Words
1:39 The worthless version of this episode
2:17 Prosecutor or witness
2:54 When my own work wasn't successful
3:43 What worries me: going quiet
4:23 The check: three questions, 90 seconds
4:43 Does this apply to my own work?
5:24 Am I describing a decision or a person?
5:59 What would change my mind?
6:37 The opening sentence
7:23 Going first: the price of standing
7:55 Resource: What Values Conflict Costs You
8:49 Where this goes wrong
9:49 Said it plainly: Dr. Melissa Hope Ditmore
11:17 Recap

RESOURCES
• What Values Conflict Costs You, Shane's TEDx talk: https://www.shanelukas.com/speaking/tedx-values-conflict
• Unbroken Chains: The Hidden Role of Human Trafficking in the American Economy, Dr. Melissa Hope Ditmore (2023)
• Encyclopedia of Prostitution and Sex Work, edited by Dr. Melissa Hope Ditmore
  (Disclosure: Dr. Ditmore wrote a quote for Shane's book.)
• Start at Episode 01: https://insomanywordspodcast.com/episodes/01-nobody-will-name-it-for-you
• Episode 02 + the free Narrative Defense Audit: https://insomanywordspodcast.com/episodes/02-you-made-a-decision-did-anyone-write-it-down

In So Many Words with Shane Lukas
https://insomanywordspodcast.com

Free resource from this episode

The Implication Test

Free, no sign-up. Word and PDF.

Download it →

Try it on your own org

Take the Language & Exposure Check-up

Twelve questions, five minutes, a scored result.

Start the check-up →

Found your org in this one? Let's talk.

Bring the documents. Shane will help you sort out what changed, who decided, and what to say instead.

Book a session with Shane

Transcript

0:00A critique that cannot include the person making it

A critique that cannot include the person making it is not analysis. It's advocacy with a better posture.

And in our line of work, the critic almost always wrote some of the sentences. That doesn't take away your standing. It just changes you from prosecutor to witness. And the witness is the one with something worth hearing.

Three questions. Does it apply to me? Am I describing a decision or a person? What would change my mind?

0:32Two episodes in, and the obvious problem with me saying this

For two episodes now I have been describing a sector that quietly changed its language and never wrote down why.

There's an obvious problem with me saying that. I'm a brand communications strategist. I work with organizations and purpose-led companies, and they hire me to decide how they describe themselves — how they picture themselves.

And if the language of the sector drifted, I was not watching from the shore. I was navigating at least one of those ships.

So this episode is about what you do when the critique includes you. When you're doing transformative work, that matters. By the end you'll have three questions and one opening sentence — and between them, they're the difference between being heard and being managed.

1:13What this show is

This is In So Many Words. Hard truths for nonprofit and mission-driven communicators. I'm Shane Lukas. I carry with me more than two decades — maybe three now — of experience, including more than ten owning an agency.

If this is your first oneI keep it to one argument and one thing to do, every two weeks. No guests, no panels, no both-sides. Quick, and helpful. That's the goal.

1:39The worthless version of this episode

Let me set the trap properly, because there is a version of this episode that is worthless.

The worthless version is the one where I admit I'm complicit, I feel bad about it on tape, and then I carry on making exactly the same argument with a clear conscience.

That's not accountability. That is buying an indulgence.

1:55The real question

The question is not whether you are implicated in a decision that might not advance the transformative work you want to do, or isn't as effective as you wish it were. In communications, you almost certainly are part of that equation.

The question is whether being implicated changes what you are allowed to say — and if so, how.

2:14Prosecutor or witness

Here's my answer, and then I'll show you the working. Being implicated does not disqualify you. It changes the shape of what you can honestly claim. Specifically, it moves you from prosecutor to witness.

A prosecutor saysthis is wrong, and here's who did it.

A witness saysI was there, here's what I saw. I saw this messaging change. I was part of that. Here's what I did, here's what I would do differently, here's what I'm learning from it, and here's what I'm trying to accomplish.

It is also the only one of the two you are actually qualified to be, if you were part of the thing.

2:52Where this happened to me

I've had that experience. Working with an organization that was trying to navigate the differences between its past and its present as it moved forward. I was part of the solution. I was part of the strategy. And I was proud of it — we followed good processes, we had the focused conversations, we had all of it there.

But at the same time there were fundamental challenges that I certainly participated in. And at the end of the day, one of the big ones is that it just wasn't successful.

So I had to come back and sayI need to spend some time really looking at what it was in this process that didn't work. It didn't drive enough of the transformative work I wanted it to. The language is a little soft. I would like it to be stronger.

That can happen around visuals. It can happen around any number of components of a strategy — where you end up somewhere you don't want to be.

3:46Why going quiet is the worse answer

And that's not what worries me. This is.

Most people in that position resolve it the other way. They decide that because they're implicated they have no standing, and they go quiet. They step out of the conversation.

It can read as integrity. It can feel like the humble option. But look at what it actually produces: the only people still talking about the sector's language are the ones who never had to write any of it.

The people who construct it have to be part of those conversations. Otherwise the field gets commentary from the uninvolved and silence from the experienced. That's a terrible trade — and we make it on purpose.

4:23The check: three questions, ninety seconds

So here's a method. A check, to help those of us who work in communications do this job a little better — and something I try to apply to myself.

Three questions, ninety seconds. Run them before you say the thing. And by run, I mean think about it before you do it. Then one sentence to open with.

4:36Question one — does this apply to my own work?

Question one. Does this apply to my own work by the same standard?

Notdo I feel bad. Concretely. If I ran the criticism I am about to make across my own last three projects, would it return a hit?

And if yes — and it usually is yes, none of us are perfect — then say so first. Not as a disclaimer at the end, where it costs nothing. In the opening sentence, where it costs something.

If you genuinely cannot find one of those moments — a piece of work that wasn't successful, or was softer than you wanted it to be — that's a good moment to be suspicious of yourself. In communications, “I've never done this” almost always means “I haven't looked that hard.”

5:26Question two — a decision or a person?

Question two. Am I describing a decision or a person?

Try restating your criticism with no human subject in it. If you can — for example, “the language changed and no review was scheduled” — you're analyzing.

If you cannot, if the sentence collapses without somebody in it, you are blaming. Blaming isn't a worse argument. It's a different activity. It's something you are doing to someone rather than something you are finding out. And the room will respond accordingly — it reads as a lack of ownership, a lack of clear accountability.

5:58Question three — what would change my mind?

Question three. What would change my mind? Answer it out loud, before anybody asks.

I would drop this. I would change this, if it turned out there was a reason I don't know about. Or: we could evolve it this way. I'm not committed to it in this form — I want to make sure it gets to this value.

If there's no answer — if nothing would change your mind — you're not making a claim. You're stating a position. There's nothing wrong with that. There is something wrong with stating a position while presenting as an analyst. And people can tell.

6:35The opening sentence

Now the sentence. This is the part I'd actually write down.

When you open, lead with your own self-application. One clause, no self-pity in it:

Before I say anything about how we have been describing this — I wrote some of it, so some of this lands on me too.

OrI designed some of it. Or: this was my strategy, so I share some of this.

That's the whole opener. Thirteen words of implication, and then straight into the substance.

What it does is remove the only easy move available to the room, which is to decide that this is about your blamelessness rather than about the work. You've conceded that in advance. There's nothing to attack and nothing to defend, and the conversation has to be about the thing.

7:18Passing the check means you go first

And then the part that costs something. Passing the check does not buy you a comfortable critique. It means you go first.

Your own challenge. Your own failure. The thing you found in it where you thought: this isn't really working, this isn't strong enough, this just wasn't successful. Name it out loud before anyone else in the room — not in your head.

That's the price of standing. It is not a high price, and almost nobody pays it.

But it also brings trust. It brings credibility. It brings a sense that you understand the goal of the work more than you want to spend time in your own ego.

7:55On values conflict

I'm going to share a resource here, because I know these are difficult moments. It's a values conflict, often.

So — if I can be indulgent — my own TEDx talk on values conflict. It's called What Values Conflict Costs You, and it's essentially the same idea. You're making a difficult choice, you're putting a cost out there, and you're holding the value.

If your value is this transformative work, if you want to see these things happen, then you are going to have to be ready for some level of critique.

Make sure you think about the ways you're willing to put that cost up front to get to the end goal. What values define you? That's what will determine the courage to do that kind of self-critique.

8:45Where the self-critique goes wrong

Something fundamental people get wrong here: sometimes they're a little too soft about where it lands.

So what ends up happening is that you ask the questions, it passes the test — and then you just don't say anything. I don't know what good that does.

And sometimes the implication becomes a performance, rather than really talking about the messaging issue and what we could do better. And sometimes it gets caught up in other relationships in the office, rather than focusing on what the message is.

Make sure that focus sits there tightly. It's critical.

9:32Transformative work is hard

Because transformative work is hard. And if we're committed to doing it — if we're purpose-led, not just in our day jobs but in our hearts and in who we are — then that critique, at some point, has to be owned by us. If we want to see things really change.

9:49Said It Plainly: Dr. Melissa Ditmore

Before I go, one minute on somebody whose whole career has been saying the accurate thing about a subject almost nobody describes accurately. And I have a personal connection here, so I'll disclose it.

Dr. Melissa Hope Ditmore edited the Encyclopedia of Prostitution and Sex Work — a reference book, which is the least glamorous form a person can use to talk about something that needed documenting. In full disclosure: she gave a quote for my book, and I'm grateful for it.

In 2023 she published Unbroken Chains: The Hidden Role of Human Trafficking in the American Economy. Most of us carry a picture of what trafficking is, and that picture comes from somewhere other than the evidence. Her book goes and looks — agriculture, domestic work, sales. The actual industries, the actual infrastructure, the people who profit. And she argues that community-based responses do more for trafficked people than law enforcement and immigration enforcement do.

The last chapter is called “What Kind of Help Is Truly Helpful.” That is the title of a person who is not performing. Five plain words, and a question most of the field would rather not have asked out loud. That's why I'm always impressed by her work, and I encourage you to check it out — that, and anything she does next.

11:17So say it

A critique that cannot include the person making it is not analysis. It's advocacy with a better posture.

And in our line of work, the critic almost always wrote some of the sentences. That doesn't take away your standing. It just changes you from prosecutor to witness. And the witness is the one with something worth hearing.

Sothree questions. Does it apply to me? Am I describing a decision or a person? What would change my mind? And one sentence — I wrote some of it, so some of this lands on me too.

You can get that, and the other resources, at insomanywordspodcast.com. I hope you'll like and subscribe. Three episodes in, and I'm really glad you're here. If you haven't been listening in order, go back to the first one — the audit is in those early episodes.

I'm Shane Lukas, and this is In So Many Words. If you want the critique to be real, it needs to include you. So say it. In so many words.

Next episode drops Dec 2. Follow so it finds you.

03Latest · Ep 03 · 12 minWhat If You're Part of the Problem?